Talking with faculty: mentoring and research conversations

A first conversation in office hours

Bring something specific from a course, such as a result in a class reading or a choice made during a design exercise. Describe the part that interests you and ask how someone in the field would investigate it further. If a lab in class compared how materials respond to the same test, for example, you might ask what a researcher would vary next to get a more useful comparison. A question about a decision gives the professor a clear place to begin.

Give the conversation a purpose that fits what you need. If you want to find out what work in a field looks like, bring a course topic you could imagine studying beyond class. If you have an open question from a project, bring the part you have tried to answer and the point where you got stuck. If you are ready to discuss available roles, the guide to finding a research position covers project descriptions and ways to approach a group.

End the conversation by checking what can happen next. Ask whether there is an article, course topic or method worth looking into. Write down the suggestion in enough detail to remember why it came up. On a second visit, bring a question that arose while following up. That gives the faculty member a chance to work with something you have already tried to understand.

Different kinds of research guidance

Mentorship involves using experience to give someone guidance and feedback as they develop. Mentors can bring different strengths, and a student can learn from more than one [1]. A person who can explain why a group chose a particular method may be suited to a different conversation from someone who can help you weigh possible fields of study. Decide which kind of help you are seeking before settling on a person to ask.

The principal investigator leads a research project and has responsibility for decisions about the work and its funding [3]. A postdoctoral researcher continues doing research after earning a doctorate and commonly works under a principal investigator [4]. During a conversation about a project, ask which people in the group can help you learn about the question, get comfortable with a method or interpret a result. The most useful names will depend on the kind of help you need.

Undergraduates can work independently, collaborate with faculty or students, or take part in a research program [5]. For a project you design, it can help to ask a mentor to read the question and say which part seems too broad. For work alongside a team, ask what the team has already decided about the method and where there is room to learn through trial and revision. These discussions give you a sense of where you can exercise judgment.

A plan for what to learn

The National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIGMS) describes research training as a deliberate process that starts with a trainee's interests, background and needs. Its mentoring plans include near-term and longer-term career objectives and activities to help reach them [2]. A student who wants to learn how to read scientific graphs could start by identifying a kind of graph the group uses. A longer-term goal might be interpreting a graph from a related study and explaining how its measurements support the conclusion.

NIGMS describes an individual development plan, or IDP, as a way to plan this work and improve communication between mentors and trainees, including undergraduates [2]. A short plan can name the skill, an activity that gives it practice and the evidence that will show whether it has improved. For a goal about research writing, that evidence might be a revised paragraph that explains both a result and the uncertainty around it. A paragraph gives mentor and student something specific to discuss.

The plan can also make space for career decisions and the steps needed to explore them. A student weighing graduate study could write down a research question they want to learn more about and one experience that would let them try the work. A student comparing fields might choose to read project summaries from each and ask which preparation differs. The graduate school guide explains the role of original research in doctoral study.

Feedback that leads to another attempt

NIGMS describes the development plan as a document to review and change during training [2]. A check-in can start with an example of what you tried, the result and one decision that still feels unclear. If your task was to organize measurements for a shared analysis, bring a small portion of the work and explain which entries were hard to classify. A mentor can respond to a specific choice more easily when they can see what you were comparing.

When feedback covers several problems, choose a revision you can practice on the next task. Ask what a stronger version would let a reader understand or what a more reliable measurement would look like. Make a note of the feedback in terms of an action you can try. If the activity still leaves the learning goal out of reach, discuss whether the plan needs a different kind of practice.

Questions to take to a mentor

  • What background would make it easier to understand the work behind this project?
  • Which decisions has the group already made, and which ones are still open?
  • How does a student get feedback when learning a new method?
  • What kind of work would show that a student is ready for a more independent task?
  • How would a student explore whether this field might be a fit for further study?

Choose questions for the conversation you are having. An office-hours visit about an interesting class result may end with a reading suggestion. A conversation about continuing work may give you a learning goal to write down and a piece of work to bring back for feedback. The guide to presenting research has examples of pieces a mentor can help refine, including the explanation of how a project reached its conclusion.

Sources

  1. Mentorship - Wikipedia
  2. Individual Development Plans | National Institute of General Medical Sciences
  3. Principal investigator - Wikipedia
  4. Postdoctoral researcher - Wikipedia
  5. Undergraduate research - Wikipedia